I recently watched a limited series on Netflix called His and Hers, and the opening line from the first episode stopped me on my tracks and has been playing in my mind, on repeat, ever since:
“There are at least two sides to every story. Yours and mine. Ours and theirs. His and hers. Which means someone is always lying.”
It was bold. Direct. And it has stuck with me. Not because I agreed, but because has stopped me in my tracks, unsettled something.
That line got me thinking: Are our memories lies?
Or are we simply remembering differently?
We tend to treat memory as fact. As a reliable archive of what “actually happened.”
But memory isn’t a recording. It is much closer to a story. Shaped by emotion, proximity, identity, trauma, courage, and even love.
Some memories I hold vividly. I can feel the air in the room. I can name the outfit I wore. I can hear the tone in someone’s voice. These moments are etched.
But others? Others are gone. Or vague. Or altered by time, pain, or someone else’s retelling.
That’s especially true for difficult memories.
I understand that the mind often shields us from what we’re not yet ready to process. It tucks things away—traumatic moments, confusing fragments, deeply felt wounds.
It protects us with silence.
Not erasure, but distance.
The most joyful memories rise easily.
But the hardest ones often arrive in pieces.
And sometimes, not at all.
I’ve also realized how many of my “memories” are really stories other people told me. Stories shaped by their experiences, by others’ recounting of events, and sometimes also accompanied by photos to fill in the blanks.
So, whose memory is it when someone else’s voice becomes the narrator?
When someone else’s interpretation becomes your truth?
A story repeated over time settles into your memory bank, and you can’t always tell where their version ends and yours begins.
Is that a false memory?
Not exactly. I think it’s a shared one—composite and layered.
Sometimes the photo is clearer than the event itself.
Sometimes your sibling remembers something entirely different, or something that you have no recollection of at all.
Did your brain block it out?
Or maybe your experience was just different, thus also the memory of it.
Sometimes what you recall in color, someone else recalls in grayscale.
And still, both are and feel true.
Maybe you’ve had this moment, too:
You’re sitting with a sibling or cousin, and one of you starts recounting a story. Funny, painful, or somewhere in between.
And the other person interrupts:
“That’s not how I remember it.”
And suddenly the memory shifts.
Not because you were wrong, but because your memory was different.
Maybe even totally incomplete to the other person.
I’ve had to learn to hold those differences gently.
They’re not contradictions.
They’re companion truths.
After all, does knowing their version change mine?
This is the question I keep circling back to.
To fully understand my own story, do I need everyone else’s version?
Sometimes, yes — especially if healing or accountability is involved.
But sometimes, no.
What I carry is real. Even if it doesn’t match yours.
We don’t all need to walk away from an experience with the same lesson.
We don’t all need to remember the exact same sequence.
That doesn’t make us dishonest.
It makes us human.
For as long as I can remember, I have valued honesty and the power in curiosity.
And memories, multi-faceted and different as they are, have always been interesting to me.
It is fascinating to me that there can be so many accounts of the same event; of a memory that feels so clear and vivid as “the definitive version.”
And as I get older, I find myself less attached to having “the definitive version” and more curious about what others remember.
It is this that has been driving my desire to learn more about my own mother’s story so I can better understand mine.
I think knowing “her story” and hearing “her memories” would complement my story and my memories.
And not necessarily because of a need for certainty, adjustment, or correction to my own accounts,
but because I want to understand how they experienced it.
Not to invalidate myself, but to expand the story.
Because memory, like truth, is rarely singular.
It lives in layers.
And that brings me back to that opening line…
“Which means someone is always lying.”
Maybe not.
Maybe someone is remembering through a different lens.
Maybe someone’s mind did what it had to do to survive.
Maybe someone forgot on purpose. Or needed more time.
Maybe someone wants to remember but just can’t.
And maybe, in holding space for all of that, we find something truer than accuracy.
We find understanding.